Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Von's avatar

>>First, are the characters described clearly, in a way that helps you picture them?

Yes. I would quibble a bit with some of the paragraphing, but overall, yes. Indeed if anything they are too well described, leaving this 'prolouge' more of a 'let me describe some characters for you' kind of feel (data dump).

>>And second, would reading this make you want to keep reading the (as yet unwritten) first chapter of the book?

Yes. Particularly the poem and first and last paragraphs, with a bit of the second to last thrown in. I would like to have had a bit of parallelism with the 'Learners' for the fourth one's robe, even if it was just 'of a common laborer' or some such. For me it is kind of like you had said, "Three men sat in a room, two of them in a postal workers uniform, the last in pants and shirt'... ie the category 'postal worker' is not contrasted with 'civilian' or whatever, the last character is just described.

Anyway I think this is a good start and I'm looking forward to reading more.

(More critical comments available upon request. I've been told I'm too negative :) )

Expand full comment
Von's avatar

It would be nice if you would append the 'I"m looking for comments about X and Y' at the bottom of this post.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts