Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Von's avatar

A couple of quick comments, hopefully more later:

1) There are a lot of references that are a bit obscure, that could use more explanation in the text. Stuff that the character might know, but I don't.

2) I find the whole 'tradition' conversation very weak. I'm trying to imagine anyone actually having that conversation and using the word 'tradition' so many times with so little background. Usually, and I'm thinking Jewish now, they would tie the word 'tradition' to something it is supposed to do. Like "Our tradition teaches us to wipe our mouths from right to left in order to show that Moses was more important than Aaron'. I have a hard time imagining them just repeating 'tradition' ad nasueum without relating it to some deeper philosophical comment.

Expand full comment
Von's avatar

>>It came for me many times in the months and years following my Naming Day, always the same but somehow always different

This is always an interesting POV question. When using first person POV when is it helpful to give us a summary of years into the future? Does it break us out of the story? Does it lower tension?

Because, if this is going to 'come to her' many times in the next few years... she will be alive the next few years. All tension of her dying in two days is now gone. Even two years. She is now untouchable as far as the story is concerned.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts